On Saturday, Nov. 7, the Blue Bloods star dined at a Marshland restaurant location in Plymouth, Mass. and left his server, Denise Andrews, a $2,020 tip on a $35.27 bill. "A very special thank you to our friend @donniewahlberg! When asked about it all he said was 'who’s up next?!'" the restaurant wrote on Instagram on Wednesday. They also posted a photo of Wahlberg's receipt, which included the Boston native's handwritten tip, signature and the #2020tipchallenge hashtag. "Donnie has been here before in the past and he always asks for [Denise]," Marshland restaurant owner Marty Finch, 56, tells PEOPLE. "He had his normal order: steak tips with some grilled asparagus and some poached eggs. She always knows what he wants." Andrews may have known the New Kids on the Block star's regular order, but she was not expecting what came next. "When he left he just said, ‘Denise you’re all set. The payment is on the table,'" Finch says. "She always says he’s a very good tipper anyway but her jaw dropped, to say the least, when she saw that amount of tip."
Photo Credit: Getty Images